Medhurst is good and all, I just wish he wouldn't give away a 50 almost every week. He gets all ****ty everytime he gets a call against him, which ends up costing us with the opposition kicking a goal!

I have no doubt that he's a valuable addition to our side, he just needs to control his temper sometimes!

He is fantabulous! As are all the people the dockers end up sending to the pies eg Clement and Holland. Poor freo just can't get anything right!

Yep, Medders has been an outstanding pickup. I thought he was a pretty ordinary trade when I heard about it, but I'm very happy to admit I was totally wrong.

As a magpies supporter that lives in perth, and someone who hates both the eagles and dockers I was slow to warm to medhurst, But now I'll be one of the first to admit he has really became an awesome player.. must be what happens when you trade purple for black and white Is definately one of the pies finest atm.. now if we can score cousins next year...

just a note too make this sound even better, we got Medhurst and pick 10 in the draft that year which was used to snare Jonathan Brown has has massive potential. Even better hay.... so worth gettin rid of Tarrant

bloody oath i said as soon as we got rid of tarrant we got the better deal look a freo everyone they have traded to different clubs have performed but we def got the best deal by far!!! running a muck atm

Medders is a star. What a performance yesturday a deserving winner of the Anzac Medal. Tarrant who?