I love all our players and believe we have a farking great team. Saying stuff like "as much as I love collingwood.." and then going on to completely bag one of the players is disgraceful. Pull ya head in all of you pissants or start supporting another team. I suggest Freo you'll have plenty to bag there

You must be insane.. If you haven't got guys like Mad Maxy we wouldn't get even close. His skills aren't his strong point but, putting your body on the line, tackling, sheppards and applying pressure win games too, just like Gavin Brown..

Anthony Rocca, hes a ****** and must go, where I dont care, just gotta go...

i don´t dislike any player but i think josh fraser hasn´t lived to the no 1 draft pick expectations
especially for a big man

I dislike Rhyce Shaw the most. He does get big possession numbers each game but he quite regularly gives up the ball to the opposition. So does shane o'bree.

I don't dislike any pies players, although Chris Egan disappoints me as he is so inconsistent and stuffs up alot, he needs to keep things simple and not show-off.

I totally disagree with people disliking Nick Maxwell, I think he is a fantastic hard-working, corageous, highly skilled player and will do the number 5 justice.

i have to agree maxwell is full of himself! instead of trying to take out the smallest bloke on the field (marc murphy) put your body on the line and bloke fev's run! that's tuff

I don't dislike any of the Pies players, but the one who disappoints me most is Chris Egan. He's got the natural skill & pace to be a fantastic player, but his work rate & hardness at the ball are pathetic at the moment. What disappoints me most is that he looked pretty good in the pre-season games, but was woeful in the first 2 home & away games this year.

The one player I don't get is Chris Egan. He's slow when he hasn't got the ball, slow in making decisions when he has got the ball, and has some terrible disposal skills. very happy when he was dropped.

I have always admired the way Nick Maxwell has played the game. Lets face it there is not a lot of him but he always trys and yesterday's love tap on Murphy was just that - Speaking of yesterday, Stanley was not ready for Senior footy - but he tried. all the boys including Heath Shaw who was consistent all day need to pull their fingers out and play the footy that we know they can!

What?? Maxwell rarely gets beaten, plays the game hard and (usually) fair, and is a great clubman. If he gets rubbed out, we will miss him sorely!

I agree. I am not a fan of Maxwell either!
I will enjoy the fact that he wont be there for the next 3 weeks.
Heath Shaw is the only player that can hold his head high after yesterday. Everyone else needs to take a look at the game and get their acts together! My ladies netball team could have played better than them yesterday! Where was the passion??

i havent got a issue with Maxwell but he is going to get a holiday for that shot on Murphy. Stanley is too slow with his disposal, O'Bree sometimes tries to do things that just arent on like in the last when we were coming back and handballs on the ground to a carlton defender and they run it up and score.
Didak yesterday was sh1t, everytime there was going to be body contact in a marking contest he pulled out. Rocca didnt do enough. Heath Shaw was sensational.