Living in WA the media over here reckon Palmer is a certain winner of the Rising Star this week. Are they kidding themselves. Cyril should win by a mile. Palmer lets be honest would not get a game in the Hawthorn side and if you think he would I challenge you to go through the Hawthorn side a find a place for him. Cyril is a better user of the ball, tackles more and kicks more goals. Palmer also butchers the ball far to often. Dont get me wrong, Palmer is a good player - but is not in the same class as Cyril.