Pies, i always loved tarrant but i dont think his heart was with Collingwood... Oh well Medhurst is awesome and im so loving him... Go Pies...

The pies got the better deal. Tarrant is lazy and getting rid of him was one of the best things the pies did.

this is a no brainer, collingwood won the trade for sure.

yep that was a good deal which worked in favour of the pies. medhurst has been awesome for the pies this year though seemed to struggle this year. Tarrant i havent seen in the best players

you got the better deal , tarrant has done crap all for us , meddy has done alot for you

i think we got the better one we got a better kicker and high flyer and they got tazza?? what u think