we definitely have something over the mag'gots... and their coach is sh'ithouse, not malthouse!

Umm Collingwood "choked in 07" emotional comment to attack another you envy.
When teams play Collingwood it is treated as a finals game, it's the ultimate test in front of a big crowd, why do think the other clubs want to play us twice??? With this means not as many wins as the season goes on.
A team that knocks off the premier by over 80 points isn't a pretender. On their day Collingwood can beat any team. With a few 50/ 50 decisions gone the Pies way instead of against the ladder would be different. Not an excuse fact! Watch the games again if you dare argue.
How is it that a central umpire can bounce a ball 20 metres towards Kangas goal and not call it back when the same umpire can call back a boundary throw in if it's bias?
Went to the Richmond v Carlton match and again shocking decisions, this year the umpires are inconsistent for periods of a game then turning the blowtorch for a qtr or so.
As a neutral supporter on saturday I couldn't believe the number of Carlton morans who don't understand the rules and get angry at the umpires for this.
Collingwood overrated well lets wait until the real football is played, yeah blues fans 'FINALS' which most of ya squad have never played.
As for people attacking Malthouse.......
Listen to his media conference after a game (his 1 after the blues game an example) he spoke about bringing out the best in any footballer on Collingwood's list. Get the best out of them you will increase the chances of getting the best football out of them. It's all about making the players good people within the community.
As for Carlton well they will cheat the salary cup and cause Essendon to miss out a chance on the premiership. Yes you have paid for this but interesting to see the support of Dick Pratt by the club after he cheated everyday Australian's of millions.
No Carlton fans shut ya gobs, you have nothing to be proud of. Your recent history is crap and you only have such a promising list because you cheated the salary cap and got the picks.

collingwood are enormous pretenders, they lack the cattle in a big way, its a struggle to name thier best players and none are what would call A+ or A grade, possibly Lockyear a B+, this was illustrated by less than 5 collingwood players making a 40 man all australian pool last year, this is from a team who finished 3rd.

i dont know how malthouse can be blamed for anything he is working miracles down there

i take it back, carlton arent that good. shows they get up for the collingwood games. lose to a **** side in essendon by 5 goals lol.
Imagine when Fev leaves at the end of the year!!!! oh dear

look u say pies arnt any good that is fine.lets just say they are inconsistant.and when they gell 2gether they can beat any one like the cats game...but then we can play like worst side ever....i think the blues are rising again which they should with that many draft picks for being crap for so many years.with judd and fev and stevens there with kids its a good mix.i dont like the blues but i think its great for footy that there are competeive again..its good cause pies 3 big rivals have been done bottom for so long.tigers and dons hav a long way yet tho...its good blues are better they should be tho..and malthouse is the best thing that happened to the pies and with th players he has had and got he has got the most out of them.at least he coaches with a good brand of footy instead of tigers swans port freo.he makes his players attack...there no one else is out ther to coach us...keep him and as for choking last year come on fair go..to beat the swans then westcoast over there and come with in cats i think thats a unreal job from finishing outside top 4.no one were going to beat the cats last year simple as that it was there year.i think pies list is in great shape

It's worth pointing out that both Collingwood and Adelaide have beaten only one top eight team apiece - so on that basis, I'd say both are overrated. Carlton too has beaten only one top eight team (although we beat them twice) and so their record is probably also flattering. But Carlton was clearly good enough to beat a Collingwood team which has an inexperienced backline and (even though they still won the knock-outs 37-31) rather poor ruck staff.

i think we r overated but Carlton r a good side but not a very good side just yet but they will be.
Collingwood have only beaten 1 side in the 8 this year. I wouldnt say they choked in the 2007 finals series lol. They beat Sydney then beat WCE over in Perth and then took the premiers to within a kick of the GF. Not bad considering they finished the season out of the top 4.
Carlton would be very happy with the kids they have. Murphy is a star and players like Simpson, Bentick, Scotland dont get the wraps they deserve.
We have no hard ball get players apart from Burns and when your oldest player is that guy then u know ur in trouble. Too many recievers and too many players who want to make things look special instead of sticking the basics.
I will say this but, the Fisher free late in the 3rd was critical and change the momentum massively. Was one of the worst frees ever. Also Medhurst free against for in the back in the 4th which would have made it 1 pt the diff was a killer. Disgusting.
Credit to Carlton 54 pt turnaround. They have a bright future

On paper Collingwood are a better team. I think we ran into the Magpies at an opportunistic time. I don't think the Pies chocked we were just better on the day. Carlton have the potential to be a top 8 side this year but Collingwood will be a top 8 side. I'm just still super psyched about yesterday's win. But as Geelong said "keep a lid on it"

How can you say Collingwood Choked in the 2007 finals series? That prelim against Geelong is more memorable to me than any Carlton game ever.

Fair enough you hate Collingwood, we all know that, but you should give credit where it's due, you guys with all the rivalry stuff need to start paying a bit more respect to the game itself, instead of trying to prove all the time that your team is better than theirs. Because there is more to supporting than hating the oposition. Fair enough, gloat about the win, it was a good win, with significance, and a great game as well. But when did every time a team looses start being refered to as "choking"? Both sides, in the 2007 final your refering to absolutely fought it out to the death. Explain to me how Collingwood choked, or did you even watch it?