why would he go back to perth, that is not his home anymore, when the hawks picked him up his family came across with him...anyway what would u trade him for, what is out there that is worth him ie age, speed, skill, strength

Are you an actual Hawks supporter mate ? come on seriously..... TURN IT UP! Were having a belter start to the year wth many great thingds to come with one of the youngest sides in the comp and you think that we should trade one of our best ? Players like buddy don't come along everyday... The Boys are on their way back to the team we had late 80's early 90's if it aint broke dont try and fix it

Haha - have you ever thought if Buddy actually wants to play at another team other than Hawthorn?? Even if he wanted to go, why would he join losers such as Dockers and Eagles??!!!! I'd know which team I'd want to play for if I was Buddy!!!!

What an idiot this person is. Do you know anything about football or are you an eagle in disguise? Must be ******

Trade Buddy!!!! Never not in a million years! Is he the full quid! That would be like tradeing a shot at a Primership straight for the wooden spoon. I think its our time to shine!!!

Are you the full tin of biscuits? Me thinks not!

this topic is **** trade buddy your a joke mate, go support another team.

Trade buddy, ur an idiot

how bout we trade mark williams and cambell brown as well or pretty much anyone not from victoria ay.

"Hawthorn's a great club, I love it here. I want to be here for another 10 years, at least," Lance Franklin, February 6, 2008.

Buddy will be "worth something" for a long time.

your a dick.

I think your not the sharpest tool in the shed!!

u call yourself a hawthorn fan...we will win the flag on buddys boot and u will eat your words...once that happens we will have enough cash (and with crawf retiring soon) to keep buddy at hawthorn for life....how dare u slander the greatest hawthorn player to ware the sacred 23 since dermy

Sorry but that is the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. Buddy brings people to the footy, and will help bring the Hawks our next premiership.

you're an idiot

Anymore smart ideas Gaz, trade Hodgey or maybe Sammy.

Well that one leg managed to kick 6.3 for us and nearly singlehandedly matching Melbournes entire score for the day. What a fool you are to want to trade him. Gary with comments like that you should be chief football writer for the age.