I would like to see him win both, as I support North Albury (the club that the Swans recruited him from)

I reckon Brett Kirk is one of the best players in the league. You gotta respect the way he plays the game. However I think he has only a slightly better chance of winning the Brownlow as I do. He just doesn't catch the attention of the umps, Garry Ablett will win the Brownlow coz umps love him. If the Swan's are to make the Grand Final I would never rule him out for a Norm Smith. but I just don't think the Swans will make it there.

I'd say Goodes is Sydneys best player, but kirk is certainly their best leader and oh great fearless leader that puts his body on the line week in week out. But, no Kirk won't win a brownlow, this year more likely Ablett or Franklin.

I love the Swans, Brett Kirk is without doubt the best player in the side, but he will never win a brownlow!! Even though he does deserve it!!!

your on drugs pal.

is he a tagger? hard in and under that doesnt get the recognition of the more decorated players in the team do?

Brett Kirk will never win a Brownlow, he just isn't noticed enough. And... Sydney would have to make the Grand Final first which is a LONG way away at this stage.

your off your head mate........the swans would have to make the g/f for him to win normie and that wont happen this year

i wouldnt have a problem if that were to happen. Star player.
Went and watched him on the weekend against Port as my wife is a Swans member and you dont understand how hard he works til u see him live. Freak.
I doubt the swans will make the GF but could win a Brownlow easily.

Good player, not a noticable one.

Yeah, and the Bombers will make the Grand Final too!

Swans in the Grand Final? I highly doubt it, nice to dream though...